ai-agent-book 精选快照（<2MB 代码与文档，来自 github.com/bojieli/ai-agent-book）

chapter9/hermes-self-evolution/review_task.md

@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+# Independent review of the first candidate
+
+An independent reviewer rejected the first candidate pending correction. Read
+the current diff and `BOOK_SELF_EVOLUTION_REPORT.md`, then address these exact
+findings without expanding scope:
+
+1. The request-local status is not prefix-stable across the tool loop. On call
+   1 it is appended to the user API copy; on call 2 that historical user copy
+   loses the status. On later calls, the previous tool result loses its old
+   status before the newest tool result gains a new one. This changes prior
+   wire bytes and invalidates the cached suffix, conflicting with Hermes'
+   byte-stability rule. Use a persistent-append design (for example, stable
+   `api_content` sidecars) or another design that proves previously sent wire
+   messages remain byte-identical. Keep clean transcript content unchanged.
+2. The tests exercise only the formatter. Add behavior-contract coverage for
+   the actual attachment/replay mechanism over at least three successive API
+   requests. Assert that each earlier wire message is byte-identical in every
+   later request and that the newest status is closest to generation.
+3. Correct the report's contradictory verification wording: the repository
+   wrapper was blocked because its environment lacked pytest, but the focused
+   tests did execute and pass through `uv run --with pytest`.
+
+Run the focused tests, relevant existing replay/cache tests, compilation, and
+`git diff --check`. Update the report with the review round and exact results.
+Do not claim end-to-end benefit without an ablation campaign, do not push or
+commit, and do not edit the book repository.