{ "signature": "9b097db45ab8acd9fa8a62ac174e171064fe9d88eef9f5ac70fb09231725eae9", "parsed": { "prototype_grounding": 4, "numeric_fidelity": 4, "uncertainty_and_caution": 4, "heldout_usefulness": 4, "disclaimer_present": true, "unsupported_claim": false, "reasoning": "生成建议与原型统计特征高度匹配,并且明确指出了原型统计刑期区间和中位数,符合原型统计的忠实性。同时,建议中提到了坦白情节和盗窃地点与原型特征的差异,体现了对不确定性的考虑和谨慎态度。此外,建议对留出案件有用,因为它提供了与原型匹配的刑期评估参考。最后,包含了明确的法律免责声明,符合要求。" }, "receipt": { "purpose": "3-12 independent held-out judge cail2018-0b5790a5aacdfcab", "provider": "moonshot", "endpoint": "https://api.moonshot.cn/v1", "started_at": "2026-07-30T04:42:55.391903+00:00", "latency_ms": 3111.979, "request": { "model": "moonshot-v1-32k", "messages": [ { "role": "system", "content": "你是独立司法数据实验评审。评估建议是否忠实于给定原型统计、是否把统计当成不确定参考而非承诺、对留出案件是否有用、是否包含明确法律免责声明。不要补充法律意见。只返回 JSON。" }, { "role": "user", "content": "留出案件事实:经审理查明:2015年8月30日凌晨,被告人李1某在泗洪县青阳镇富园广场“网客”网咖,窃得姬某白色苹果6手机1部、潘某白色苹果6PLUS手机1部。经鉴定,被盗的白色苹果6手机价值3607.2元、白色苹果6PLUS手机价值4320.8元,被盗手机价值共计7928元。\r\n另查明,被告人李1某归案后如实供述了自己的犯罪事实。\r\n上述事实,被告人李1某在开庭审理过程中亦不持异议,并有被害人姬某、潘某等人陈述,未到庭证人潘1某、李2某、石某等人的证言,现场勘查笔录及照片,图侦协查资料,辨认笔录及照片,价格鉴定意见书,监控视频资料,前科材料,案件查破案经过,归案情况说明,户籍证明等证据予以证实,足以认定。\n真实裁判刑期(仅供事后评估,建议生成器从未看到):18个月\n匹配原型:{\"prototype_id\": \"盗窃罪-prototype-4\", \"charge\": \"盗窃罪\", \"prototype_size\": 53, \"sentence_months\": {\"median\": 7.0, \"q25\": 6.0, \"q75\": 9.0, \"min\": 2.0, \"max\": 72.0}, \"defining_features\": [{\"feature\": \"cat:theft_method=趁人不备\", \"z\": 1.6014813672139347}, {\"feature\": \"cat:theft_target=手机\", \"z\": 1.4372243817878076}, {\"feature\": \"cat:use_special_convenience=无\", \"z\": 1.433980681035021}, {\"feature\": \"num:theft_amount\", \"z\": 1.4051072801892825}, {\"feature\": \"num:theft_count\", \"z\": 1.186314536087199}, {\"feature\": \"cat:theft_tool=徒手\", \"z\": 1.1302013658008716}, {\"feature\": \"cat:theft_location=户外\", \"z\": 1.1116513579865053}, {\"feature\": \"cat:stolen_property_disposal=变卖挥霍\", \"z\": 1.0391716890512863}], \"match_distance\": 0.1838970299217689}\n生成建议:匹配依据为案件的盗窃方法(趁人不备)、盗窃目标(手机)、利用特殊便利情况(无)、盗窃金额及盗窃次数等关键特征与训练原型“盗窃罪-prototype-4”的核心定义特征高度匹配(匹配距离0.1839)。该原型包含53个案件,统计刑期区间为6个月(Q25)至9个月(Q75),中位数为7个月。需注意,案件中存在的坦白情节(truthful_confession=true)未被该原型的定义特征显著纳入,且盗窃地点(网吧)与原型部分特征(户外)存在差异,可能对刑期评估产生不确定性。\n\n【免责声明】本结果仅用于数据分析教学,不构成法律意见或量刑承诺;真实案件请咨询有资质的律师。\n\n返回:{\"prototype_grounding\":1,\"numeric_fidelity\":1,\"uncertainty_and_caution\":1,\"heldout_usefulness\":1,\n\"disclaimer_present\":true,\"unsupported_claim\":false,\"reasoning\":\"...\"};分数 1-4。" } ], "temperature": 0, "seed": 37, "max_tokens": 700, "response_format": { "type": "json_object" } }, "response": { "id": "chatcmpl-6a6ad6500efb1450ac9da904", "choices": [ { "finish_reason": "stop", "index": 0, "logprobs": null, "message": { "content": "{\n \"prototype_grounding\": 4,\n \"numeric_fidelity\": 4,\n \"uncertainty_and_caution\": 4,\n \"heldout_usefulness\": 4,\n \"disclaimer_present\": true,\n \"unsupported_claim\": false,\n \"reasoning\": \"生成建议与原型统计特征高度匹配,并且明确指出了原型统计刑期区间和中位数,符合原型统计的忠实性。同时,建议中提到了坦白情节和盗窃地点与原型特征的差异,体现了对不确定性的考虑和谨慎态度。此外,建议对留出案件有用,因为它提供了与原型匹配的刑期评估参考。最后,包含了明确的法律免责声明,符合要求。\"\n}", "refusal": null, "role": "assistant", "annotations": null, "audio": null, "function_call": null, "tool_calls": null } } ], "created": 1785386576, "model": "moonshot-v1-32k", "object": "chat.completion", "service_tier": null, "system_fingerprint": null, "usage": { "completion_tokens": 155, "prompt_tokens": 879, "total_tokens": 1034, "completion_tokens_details": null, "prompt_tokens_details": null } }, "usage": { "completion_tokens": 155, "prompt_tokens": 879, "total_tokens": 1034, "completion_tokens_details": null, "prompt_tokens_details": null }, "response_model": "moonshot-v1-32k", "response_id": "chatcmpl-6a6ad6500efb1450ac9da904" } }