{
  "artifact_type": "agent_control_code_patch",
  "failure_cluster": [
    {
      "cluster_id": "charge_card:PAYMENT_DECLINED",
      "tool": "charge_card",
      "error_code": "PAYMENT_DECLINED",
      "source_case_ids": [
        "run-payment-001",
        "run-payment-002"
      ],
      "cross_trajectory_support": 2,
      "total_redundant_calls": 5
    }
  ],
  "source_trajectories": [
    {
      "id": "run-payment-001",
      "trajectory_sha256": "4a0b38498b006bf988279b0ff7984f04245db21ee0668986a49f3ca3f4969008",
      "evidence": "The same declined payment was submitted four times."
    },
    {
      "id": "run-payment-002",
      "trajectory_sha256": "6407eb8005fb39702005d553963405329607b34e67acbb18901c79060dbe1e59",
      "evidence": "A second task repeated the identical non-retryable call three times."
    }
  ],
  "inferred_root_cause": "The deterministic control policy ignores retryable=false and does not open the circuit for permanent errors. The root cause belongs in retry/circuit-breaker code, not a prompt.",
  "target_component": "retry_and_circuit_breaker_control",
  "target_file": "stable/retry_policy.py",
  "code_diff": "--- stable/retry_policy.py\n+++ candidate/retry_policy.py\n@@ -1,16 +1,18 @@\n \"\"\"Stable version 1.0.0. It intentionally contains the reproduced bug.\"\"\"\n \n-VERSION = \"1.0.0\"\n+VERSION = \"1.0.1-rejected\"\n MAX_RETRIES = 3\n CIRCUIT_BREAKER_THRESHOLD = 5\n NON_RETRYABLE_CODES = {\"AUTH_DENIED\", \"INVALID_ARGUMENT\"}\n \n \n def should_retry(error_code, retryable, attempt):\n-    \"\"\"Return whether another tool call should be attempted.\"\"\"\n-    return attempt < MAX_RETRIES\n+    \"\"\"Incorrect over-broad fix retained as a rejected candidate.\"\"\"\n+    return False\n \n \n def should_open_circuit(consecutive_failures, *, error_code=\"\", retryable=True):\n-    \"\"\"Open after repeated failures.\"\"\"\n+    \"\"\"Open immediately for permanent errors; otherwise use the threshold.\"\"\"\n+    if not retryable or error_code in NON_RETRYABLE_CODES:\n+        return consecutive_failures >= 1\n     return consecutive_failures >= CIRCUIT_BREAKER_THRESHOLD\n",
  "impact_prediction": {
    "non_retryable_calls": {
      "after": 1
    },
    "temporary_timeout_recovery_rate": {
      "after": 0.0
    }
  },
  "expected_fix": [
    "non-retryable tool-call attempts fall to one",
    "the circuit opens on the first permanent failure"
  ],
  "potential_regressions": [
    "temporary timeouts stop retrying",
    "the five-failure circuit threshold changes for retryable errors",
    "public function signatures change"
  ],
  "stable_version": "fcd37db6ebb1",
  "stable_sha256": "fcd37db6ebb19ed2e2492f086365a9f8addfcc4410242151185a1481d130041a",
  "candidate_version": "824bbfb244a7",
  "candidate_sha256": "824bbfb244a7b17ac835706be588542a63ad03e0d737d6c9d5da719c969652d2",
  "rollback_version": "fcd37db6ebb1",
  "rollback_sha256": "fcd37db6ebb19ed2e2492f086365a9f8addfcc4410242151185a1481d130041a",
  "diff": "--- stable/retry_policy.py\n+++ candidate/retry_policy.py\n@@ -1,16 +1,18 @@\n \"\"\"Stable version 1.0.0. It intentionally contains the reproduced bug.\"\"\"\n \n-VERSION = \"1.0.0\"\n+VERSION = \"1.0.1-rejected\"\n MAX_RETRIES = 3\n CIRCUIT_BREAKER_THRESHOLD = 5\n NON_RETRYABLE_CODES = {\"AUTH_DENIED\", \"INVALID_ARGUMENT\"}\n \n \n def should_retry(error_code, retryable, attempt):\n-    \"\"\"Return whether another tool call should be attempted.\"\"\"\n-    return attempt < MAX_RETRIES\n+    \"\"\"Incorrect over-broad fix retained as a rejected candidate.\"\"\"\n+    return False\n \n \n def should_open_circuit(consecutive_failures, *, error_code=\"\", retryable=True):\n-    \"\"\"Open after repeated failures.\"\"\"\n+    \"\"\"Open immediately for permanent errors; otherwise use the threshold.\"\"\"\n+    if not retryable or error_code in NON_RETRYABLE_CODES:\n+        return consecutive_failures >= 1\n     return consecutive_failures >= CIRCUIT_BREAKER_THRESHOLD\n",
  "patch_size": {
    "added_lines": 6,
    "deleted_lines": 4,
    "changed_lines": 10
  },
  "checks": {
    "static_compile": true,
    "security_scan": true,
    "sandbox_execution": true,
    "public_api_compatible": true,
    "failure_replay": true,
    "nonretryable_circuit": true,
    "temporary_recovery": false,
    "old_task_regression": false,
    "canary_ready": false,
    "rollback_ready": true,
    "protected_surfaces_unchanged": true
  },
  "failed_checks": [
    "temporary_recovery",
    "old_task_regression",
    "canary_ready"
  ],
  "canary_gate": {
    "eligible": false,
    "scope": "shadow traffic only; stable remains unchanged",
    "rollback_trigger": "any non-retryable repeat or temporary-recovery regression"
  },
  "rollback_gate": {
    "artifact_hash_matches_stable": true,
    "rollback_version": "fcd37db6ebb1"
  },
  "provenance": {
    "generator": "negative_control",
    "api_calls": 0
  },
  "decision": "reject_candidate",
  "rejection_reason": "failed gates: temporary_recovery, old_task_regression, canary_ready"
}